The YP thread

[ddraig]

Ok but at the end of the day are you looking at his talent at the expense of his skills? Are you neglecting his ability to be a world class batsman , to be a spectacular bowler?

lol, world class batsman, the only way he'd get to that is if he was trained in just batting and I ignored most of his secondaries.

Are we talking about the prodigy wmchamps posted
He will make WC easy with excep power and field in high level academies

Yep the prodigy would, virtually without question, if he were trained that way. We're talking about MacNamara, who wouldn't.

[GM-crowfan65]

he will make WC primary with spec power and field halfway thru 29 in high-end academy

[ddraig]

he will make WC primary with spec power and field halfway thru 29 in high-end academy

Macnamara?

Seems unlikely to me, how did you work that out? His technique only increased to poor on the 12th April, and I can't see much spare in his batting.

Although I'd want his fielding higher than that anyway.

[GM-crowfan65]

You realise I can see the sublevels and I have known how much trng etc they get since season 2
I made a spreadsheet that I can paste a player in and fiddle with their trng
Even an extra level of field he still makes it


@klauts I run del/del

[GM-crowfan65]

yeah its a few weeks, not sure exactly but I could work it out

[GM-crowfan65]

yeah about 6 plus an extra week or two for field and strength overall, still sneaks in with lux/lux

[ddraig]

lol, world class batsman, the only way he'd get to that is if he was trained in just batting and I ignored most of his secondaries.


Ever heard of summary champ? Never said primary world class.

That's pretty meaningless, and even Bannerman (who you've dissed many times) is a World Class Batsman when his form is higher!

By the way I didn't mention summary either, but I know what you meant and you know what I meant.

Bannerman wasn’t dissed just dismissed , there is a difference between summary and primaries , summary is adjusted by form and world class summary at spectacular primaries doesn’t cut it for national touring, there is too many variables that affect him (form) that an exceptional primary player would not be as hugely affected by .

It does, however, make your point moot. A batsmen that is summarised as world class isn't actually that good, and therefore training him to reach that summary level (whatever that means) isn't really a great reason to do that.

[GM-crowfan65]

Guys, you clearly don't agree
Walk away and leave it be AGAIN

[ddraig]

You realise I can see the sublevels and I have known how much trng etc they get since season 2
I made a spreadsheet that I can paste a player in and fiddle with their trng
Even an extra level of field he still makes it


@klauts I run del/del

Deluxe / Deluxe is a pretty high level, but I'm surprised he'd make that.

I do most of the calcs in my head, and I couldn't see him getting near that, my academies are "only" lavish/superior but they're still pretty decent.

Perhaps I should create a spreadsheet too, I have most of the raw data I require, but I generally can't be bothered

[ddraig]

Guys, you clearly don't agree
Walk away and leave it be AGAIN

No problem, I'm walking away from the forum, I don't post much anyway.

[ddraig]

I have just walked away, not sure what the point is, and I have respect for the vast majority of users here.

Sadly that's my final post, in Scotland, but c'est la vie as they say.